Bluefield Daily Telegraph, Bluefield, WV

January 10, 2014

Company working to determine size of W.Va. chemical spill as federal probe launched

By Pamela Pritt
Beckley Register-Herald


West Virginia American Water president Jeff McIntyre said Friday that he could not say if the water his company provides to 100,000 customers is not safe. But he couldn’t assure them that it is safe, either.

As for when water customers in a nine-county area can return to normal water usage, McIntyre could offer no timeline. The counties are Boone, Cabell, Clay, Jackson, Kanawha, Lincoln, Logan, Putnam and Roane.

Thursday afternoon, a chemical that McIntyre said his company doesn’t test for because “it isn’t supposed to be in the water,” entered the intake system on the Elk River. The substance, 4-methylcyclohexane methanol, a frothing agent used to clean coal, leaked from a 40,000 gallon tank at the Freedom Industries chemical plant, then leached through the soil into the river. It then entered the water company’s system about 2 p.m. By 4 p.m. the filtration system could no longer handle the amount of contamination in the water, McIntyre said.

McIntyre said he did not yet know a quantity that may have leached into the water, but a state Department of Environmental Protection spokesperson said he was “confident no more than 5,000 gallons escaped.”

“A certain amount of that got into the river,” said the DEP’s Tom Aluise. “Some of that was contained.”

No production or actual coal cleaning goes on at the Freedom Industries facility on the Elk River, where he said the company operates a tank farm for storage. The leaky tank is close to the river, Aluise said. The chemical, which is not water soluble and may look like cooking oil, will dissipate as it floats downstream, he advised.

Aluise said he didn’t know if the chemical is corrosive, nor did he have any information on what caused the leak.

According to a fact sheet from Fisher scientific, the chemical is harmful if swallowed — and could be so if inhaled — and causes eye and skin irritation.

The spill caused a state of emergency in Kanawha and eight other counties where West Virginia American Water customers reside. Restaurants in Charleston were closed immediately, and grocery store shelves were stripped of bottled water early in the evening. Schools in the region were closed Friday.

U.S. Attorney Booth Goodwin announced Friday that his office is investigating the incident.

“Yesterday’s release of a potentially dangerous chemical into our water supply has put hundreds of thousands of West Virginians at risk, severely disrupted our region’s economy and upended people’s daily lives,” Goodwin said. “My office and other federal law enforcement authorities have opened an investigation into the circumstances surrounding the release. We will determine what caused it and take whatever action is appropriate based on the evidence we uncover.”

Sen. Daniel Hall, D-Wyoming, was part way through his plate of wings at a local sports bar where he and fellow legislators had gathered to watch a game about 6:30 p.m. Hall said he got a text message about the ban on water use, then started following local news media on Twitter. The restaurant stopped all new orders, he said.

While Hall didn’t notice anything unusual about the water or the reported smell of licorice in the air, he said others he knew had.

“Friends who work in the area could smell it all day,” Hall said.

The West Virginia Legislature is in the first week of its annual session.

The “No Use” order, which means that water can only be used to flush toilets and fight fires, was issued as a precaution, officials said, because they are still not sure what, if any, risk the spill poses to residents.

McIntyre said his company won’t know that until they know the health standards for the diluted chemical.

Paul Ziemkiewicz, director of the West Virginia Water Research Institute at WVU said a 3,000 gallon spill would translate to 41 milligrams per liter in the Elk River and 6 milligrams per liter in the Kanawha River using data available now.

"Those are pretty low concentrations," he said. "You would have to drink thousands of gallons of that water to get anywhere near a lethal dose."

Still, he said, showering would not be a good idea, because the chemical could irritate the skin and lungs.

West Virginia American Water has had no contact with Freedom Industries, McIntyre said. The chemical company did not report the spill to the water company, he continued. McIntyre said he did not know if the neighboring company reported the leak to anyone. The DEP contacted West Virginia American Water, McIntyre said.

Water at the plant first must be determined to be safe, then the entire system will be flushed. McIntyre said water will likely be turned on in zones rather than the entire system at one time.

Aluise said the DEP is working with personnel at Freedom Industries to approve remediation of the affected area.

— E-mail: